Radical Hope: Education and Equality in Australia
Author: Noel Pearson
Noel Pearson is a lawyer and activist, and director of the Cape York Institute for Policy and Leadership. He is passionate about improving the real education of his own aboriginal people in Australia.
In Radical Hope he sets out a withering analysis of past educational reforms and the way in which they have undermined educational achievement for aboriginal people.
He also describes how the approaches to education which have demonstrated the best outcomes have often been undermined by public policies based on ideology. In particular he points to the value of Direct Instruction (DI) and the work of Siegfried Engelmann. According to Pearson the major US research on education methods, which demonstrated the value of DI on every measure was subject to "one of the biggest frauds ever in the history of so-called evidence based policy."
Pearson also goes on to demonstrate that the problems in education reflect deep problems that sit at the heart of the welfare state's treatment of those who are disadvantaged. He writes:
Self-interest is the most powerful engine for individual and social development, in other words, social progress, in other words social justice. It is when the most disadvantaged in society have the opportunity to improve their lives in their own self-interest that change will take place. A whole lot of individual change animated by self-interest amounts to social change. Social change amounts to social justice. The provisioning of opportunity is indeed one of the key expressions of our common good; a product of social, altruistic and democratic action on the part of citizens and their government - but turning opportunity into capabilities and a better life is a product of enlightened self-interest. No anti-poverty or "social inclusion" aspiration willl get anywhere without understanding that self-interest is the driving engine.
The problem is that the advantaged classes see the salvation of disadvantaged people lying in the advantaged classes' "other-regard" rather than in the disadvantaged people's own "self-regard." Altruism must be directed at igniting, and supporting with maximum opportunity, the self-interest of the disavantaged. All other forms of altruism degenerate into welfare provision.
As Pearson notes this kind of paternalistic altruism is endemic to the welfare state and it is rooted not just in demeaning and degrading views of those who are disadvantaged. It is also self-serving for the classes who promulgate dependency and low expectations. In fact, although this book is rooted in the experiences of aboriginal people in Australia it is clear that many of its lessons apply equally as well to disadvantaged groups in all welfare states.
Pearson goes on to offer a powerful set of guiding principles for people who are in disadvantaged groups - do the opposite:
- They say substance abuse is a 'health' issue and should be approached with tolerance; we say that it is a behavioural and social order issue and we need to build intolerance
- They say education should be 'culturally appropriate'; we say that this should not be an alibi for anti-intellctualism, romantic 'indigenism' and a justification for sub-standard achievement and expectations
- The say we should respect 'Aboriginal English' as a real language; we say we should speak the Queen's English and our own languages fluently and comprehensively
- They say our people need to be defended in a hostile criminal justice system; we say we need more policing to restore law and order in our communities
- They say our people are victims and must not be 'blamed'; we say our people are victimised but we are not victims
- They say our people have rights; we say our people have responsibilities as well
- They say we have a right to passive welfare; we say we do not have a right to dependency and we in fact have a greater right to a fair place in the real economy of our country
- They say that economic development and wealth creation is somehow antithetical to our identity; we say our culture cannot and will not survive as along as we live in the social dysfunction caused by economic dependency
- They say poverty is our main problem; we say passivity is our main problem because it prevents us taking advantage of opportunities to get out of poverty, such that the resources we do get are squandered
Noel Pearson advocates a radical reversal of current welfare policies, giving genuine control and power back to local people over their own education and well-being. It is only then that he believes his people will be able to guarantee for themselves the kind of high quality education that they need. It is interesting to note that this cry tallies with the research in the UK that shows that it is the poor, above any other social group, who want increased levels of control over education and healthcare.
The publisher is Quarterly Essay.
Radical Hope: Education and Equality in Australia © Noel Pearson 2009.
Review of Radical Hope: Education and Equality in Australia © Simon Duffy 2011.
All Rights Reserved. No part of this paper may be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher except for the quotation of brief passages in reviews.