1. Home
  2. Library
  3. Assessing the Assessors

Assessing the Assessors

Authors: Rick Burgess, Simon Duffy, Nick Dilworth, Jane Bence, Wayne Blackburn and Mark Thomas

The assessment of disabled people for the Employment Support Allowance has been a national scandal. Much of the focus has been on the private healthcare firm, Atos, who have administered the DWP's assessment. But the real problem is the culture of contempt which is at the very heart of the Work Capability Assessment (WCA) itself.

This report is based on 884 respondents to an online questionnaire which asked people who were sick or disabled to assess the assessors - to describe how they were treated in the assessment process and what impact the assessment had on their lives.

The statistics are bleak, for instance:

  • 95% found the assessment damaged their health, 29% severely
  • 95% gave the assessment a mark of 5 out 10 or less, 43% gave it the lowest possible mark
  • 80% of the time the respondent felt the assessor did not listen to them

Even more bleak are the moving stories and comments left by the respondents, for example:

  • "The process was terrifying, humiliating and degrading..."
  • "Tragically, my friend has committed suicide since losing her appeal."
  • "It was the second worst experience of my life after my severe accident."

This report was developed independently, with no funding or subsidy, but with support from Mark Thomas and the team of disabled people who are now established as New Approach and who will setting out alternatives to the WCA over the coming months.

The data used in this report is also available online at: http://bit.ly/wcasurveydata

The publisher is the Centre for Welfare Reform in association with New Approach and the Campaign for a Fair Society.

Assessing the Assessors © Rick Burgess, Simon Duffy, Nick Dilworth, Jane Bence, Wayne Blackburn and Mark Thomas 2014.

All Rights Reserved. No part of this paper may be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher except for the quotation of brief passages in reviews.



Austerity Bites

Austerity Bites

Mary O'Hara's book describes the many dimensions of 'austerity' and how it is affecting the lives of ordinary people in the UK.

Counting the Cuts

Counting the Cuts

This report was one of the first quantitative analyses providing an estimate of the cumulative impact of UK Government cuts on disabled people and those in poverty.

Fulfilling Potential?

Fulfilling Potential?

In this significant report Catherine Hale explores the experience of a key group of disabled people who have been slotted into the 'Work Related Activity Group'.

How Norms Become Targets

How Norms Become Targets

Kaliya Franklin analyses the way in which the use of norms in the management of disability assessment (WCA) undermines integrity.

Next Steps on a Cumulative Impact Assessment (CIA)

Next Steps on a CIA

Simon Duffy explores the possibility of developing an even more rigorous assessment of how cuts have targeted disabled people.

Beyond the Barriers

Beyond the Barriers

A Spartacus Network report into Employment Support Allowance, the Work Programme and recommendations for a new system of support.

The People's Review of WCA Further Evidence

People's Review of WCA Further Evidence

This report provides additional evidence to the first People's Review of the Work Capability Assessment.

The People's Review of the Work Capability Assessment

The People's Review of the WCA

This report was written in response to the Work Capability Assessment (WCA) which assesses an individual’s entitlement to Employment and Support Allowance (ESA).